April 12: Reasoning fallacies


 This is very good! But I don't want to be so arrogant as to say that even as scientist I have never fallen into any of these traps ... I can only say that I always try not to, and I welcome being called on it if I do!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

April 3: How many will die?

Image
It's not clear to me whether the number of deaths predicted by the models shown at the WH briefings (100-240K) refer just to "first wave" (up to the "flattening") or to the entire course of the pandemic. I suspect it's just the former. The reason is that, even without modeling sophistication, unchecked epidemics end up affecting a large % of the population.Harvard epidemiologist Marc Lipsitch, estimates it’s “plausible” that 20 to 60 percent of adults will catch the disease w ithin a year (I have seen more dire estimates). Let's make it 40%, and that's 130M. a 1% death rate would cause 1.3 Million deaths. Social distancing doesn't "kill" the virus, it just prevents it from finding new hosts. Some authorities make it sound like with "flattening" we won the battle. The reality is that it will be the start of a long battle to slowly restart the economy and social "normalcy" while at the same time preventin
Read more

March 16: Reaching the "peak"

Here is a graph of the daily new number of coronavirus cases predicted in Italy. Note that the exponential growth continues for a few more days and finally peaks on March 18 (green is up to now - remember that the rest of the world goes day/month). This is very much like trying to predict where a hurricane will land. The difference (to pursue the analogy) is that what we do actually determines the path and strength of the hurricane! The "problem" with this is that if we m anage to lessen the impact of the virus, all measures taken will be viewed as having been "overreactions", when in fact they were what made the impact less severe. The "peak", if the prediction holds, will happen because of the draconian measures taken a week or so ago. Meanwhile infections and deaths will continue to rise. The expected result is a severely strained medical system. They are now putting beds everywhere they can find space, and basically scrambling to incre
Read more

April 12: A "blue marble" moment

Image
I just finished watching Bocelli's gift perfomance at Milan's Duomo, and I'm still wiping tears off my eyes. This was loaded with emotion for me. My city of birth. A city where most of my beloved relatives still live. A cathedral I have often been in and always inspired by, in appreciation of every person's longing for something "larger" than themselves. And here is a man, blind, unable to see the emptiness of the square in front of him (see the tiny figure in front of the Duomo), but certainly able to feel it. A beaut iful voice, singing on behalf of humanity... to hope and unity. I was suddenly struck by how this felt to me like a new "blue marble" moment, when astronauts on the moon looked up and, for the first time, saw our beautiful Earth, our home, in the sky. If there is a silver lining to this pandemic it may well be a powerful and hopefully lasting reminder of our common humanity.
Read more